Games with brilliant and mysterious stories become the subject of intense fan debates for various reasons. Players will love to dissect the many stories in these games and unravel all the mysteries contained within. However, trying to figure out how mysterious these games really are. During these conversations, however, players discover even more mysteries instead of solving existing ones.
This has led to the development of several popular fan theories for certain games, the following being the most notable. Not only do these theories make a lot of sense given the events in the game, but many people would argue that they actually contribute to the overall quality of the story!
8 The Indoctrination Theory (Mass Effect 3)
Mass effect 3 is one of the most divisive games ever made, especially because of the ending. People felt that the game didn’t take their choices into account, with the endings feeling rather lazy and not offering any sort of closure either.
This has led many people to believe the theory that Shepard was indoctrinated at some point in the trilogy, leading to the fever dream that is the end. It’s a compelling theory that puts Shepard’s actions in a new light.
7 The player character repents in hell for killing his sister (Limbo)
limbo is Playdead’s first game to become a wild and captivating adventure in its own right. A platform game that can get extremely dark at times, the story of limbo is kept vague on purpose so that most players don’t realize what’s happening until the end.
The inclusion of the main character’s sister in the game and the mysterious nature of her appearance have led many people to believe that the main character is in hell and is paying for the crime of murdering his own sister. This is why the game’s deaths are so horrific and the adventure keeps repeating after the end.
6 Squall is dead (Final Fantasy 8)
Squall is a protagonist that many people have mixed opinions about. Some people find his personality quite tense, while others understand where he comes from with his aloof nature.
Anyway, the fan theory surrounding his alleged death at the hands of Edea is pretty compelling anyway. After being pierced by her icicle, Squall returns with little to no injuries as the story slowly gets more dreamy and exaggerated. This has led many players to believe that the story after this attack on Squall is a dream, with the protagonist dead all along!
Metal Gear Solid 2 featured two major twists and turns, mainly around Raiden as the protagonist and the whole game as a simulation. The latest development surprised so many players that other games in the series have come under scrutiny as well!
That is the case with Metal Gear Solid 3, where many events indicate that the game is also a simulation in its own way. Naked Snake mistook the term Virtuous Mission for Virtual Mission, while the game also ends when the players also create a time paradox! These small examples indicate that the events of the game may be experienced again in the future.
4 The game takes place after a war (Pokemon)
One thing players will notice in pokemon is that adult males are quite scarce. Most of the characters are either elderly men or growing children like the main character himself.
This, coupled with the incessant need to fight domesticated monsters, threatened to lead to the world going through a major war, with pokemon fights are a way for everyone to compromise on wanting to start a conflict. It’s a pretty out-of-the-box but compelling fan theory that has gained a lot of traction.
3 Giygas is actually a fetus (earthbound)
The final battle against Giygas is one of the most memorable boss battles in video games. Ness and his party members must throw anything but the sink into this battle if they want the least chance of victory.
Players must travel to the past to fight against Giygas, where they must travel through the Cave of the Past that in a twisted way almost resembles a birth canal. This, coupled with Giygas’ infantile screams and unique look, has led many players to believe that this boss is actually a fetus when battled by the main party.
2 G-Man is an alien (half-life)
G-Man is one of the most mysterious characters in the half-life universe. He is almost an omnipotent being who watches the player from a distance and always plays a part in the events that shape the adventures of Gordon Freeman and other important characters in the series.
While many people assume he is a government agent, this fan theory takes a very different look. It discusses the likelihood that the G-Man is an alien who explores Earth and manipulates events for his own amusement.
1 Chara was the narrator the whole time (Undertale)
undertale is one of the best indie games ever made, and its writing style is filled to the brim with charm. It’s also a game that can take quite a dark turn if players decide to take the Genocide route.
This reveals the presence of Chara, the first human to fall into the realm of monsters that caused untold death and destruction during their time there. Most people believe that the narrator – who has shown his own feelings on several occasions – is actually Chara herself, which is indeed a pretty stunning theory.
0 Comments